Supreme Court’s guidelines on tree valuation offer ray of hope


It has happened for the first time in India. A Supreme Court-appointed technical committee has estimated the value of a tree at 74,500 rupees multiplied by its age. This monetary valuation of the tree was made by a panel of experts which submitted its report to the apex court recently. The report will help frame the guidelines on the estimation and valuation of trees that are axed during land acquisition processes.
The panel of experts told the Supreme Court bench, headed by Chief Justice S A Bobde, that a heritage tree serves the society as well as the environment and its valuation can be reached on various counts including oxygen, micro-nutrients, compost, and bio-fertilizer. A heritage tree is a large tree that takes decades or centuries to mature and includes tree species like banyan, pinus, chinar and many other varieties. The report will help affected people especially the farmers and orchardists whose fruit or non-fruit bearing trees are axed during the various land acquisition processes in India.


The affected farmers in Kashmir — particularly in Budgam and Srinagar — are now expected to get fair compensation for the trees that are coming in the alignment of the Srinagar Ring Road project. The report submitted before the Supreme Court panel might prove to be helpful for the affected farmers as they have been deprived of fair compensation for the land and trees especially the fruit-bearing trees.

“The monetary valuation prepared by SC appointed panel will definitely help the affected fruit growers or even those people whose non-fruit bearing trees like poplar, willows, kickers etc are to be axed for paving a way for this alternate highway construction,” said Syed Nasarullah executive member of Srinagar based Environmental Policy Group. “As far as land is concerned that is still in the  possession of farmers in several villages especially in Wathoora area where no compensation has been paid. The Government wants to grab land under the repealed J-K land acquisition act which is unacceptable.”
Nasrullah said that a fresh notification has to be issued as per the Right to Fair compensation law that is applicable in J-K since 31 October 2019. The Jammu and Kashmir High Court, too, has already given a direction in this regard in an interim order “but for the last four months, the J-K administration has failed to submit its response,” he said.
The Supreme Court-appointed committee in its report further said that a heritage tree with a lifespan of well over 100 years could be valued at more than ₹1 crore and also that the monetary worth of a project for which hundreds of trees are proposed to cut down is far less than the economic and environmental worth of these trees which are being cut down due to the project. It is pertinent to mention that a private company recently chopped down, without prior permission or intimation, hundreds of trees for the ongoing Zojila tunnel project in the forests of Sonamarg. Will the administration now realise the costs, as per the guidelines, from the company and complicit forest officials?


The committee report that was made public on Wednesday, states that if all costs are added and multiplied by the remaining age of a tree, in the present case 100 years, the grand total would be 74,500 rupees per tree year. Out of this, the cost of oxygen alone is 45,000 rupees a year, followed by the cost of biofertilizers, which is valued at 20,000 rupees. The report had also stated that upon adding the costs of micronutrients and compost, living trees will more than not outweigh the benefits of the projects for which they are being cut down for.

Farmers in Wathoora, Gudsathoo, Ichgam and Ranbirgrah villages in Budgam and Srinagar districts have been demanding that assessment of fruit trees like apple, plum, pear, etc be made as per the present market value of the fruit. But the affected farmers were paid a meager compensation a few years back which was estimated as per rates dating back to the year 1995 —  16 rupees per kilogram of apple and 13 rupees for a kilogram of plum. Some farmers have also alleged that the volume of fruit output per tree was also not properly factored in during valuation.

The J-K administration must take the lead in implementing the Supreme Court’s guidelines and extend much-needed succor to the public.

The Kashmir Walla needs you, urgently. Only you can do it.

We have always come to you for help: The Kashmir Walla is battling at multiple fronts — and if you don’t act now, it would be too late. 2020 was a year like no other and we walked into it already battered. The freedom of the press in Kashmir was touching new lows as the entire population was gradually coming out of one of the longest communication blackouts in the world.

We are not a big organization. A few thousand rupees from each one of you would make a huge difference.

The Kashmir Walla plans to extensively and honestly cover — break, report, and analyze — everything that matters to you. You can help us.

Choose a plan as per your location

More from reporting

‘We are fed up… will quit this business’: Jhelum’s houseboat owners in dismay

At around 5:30 am on 5 September, when the Shagoo family was in deep slumber in their houseboat, the...

In near-constant lockdowns, Kashmir’s economy is in tatters

After rowing a shikara for three decades in Srinagar’s picturesque Dal Lake, Ali Mohammad took a loan of five...

Heroin ‘epidemic’ in Kashmir: Female patients’ lonely battles and stigma

Covering her face with the corner of her headscarf, Asma* was hesitant as she walked through the narrow corridors...

Final moments of Geelani: a broken door, resisting family, and chaos

The Kashmir Walla spoke to Syed Ali Shah Geelani's sons, who were with him when he passed away, to explain what happened before and after his death until he was buried.
- Advertisement -

Most Read This Week

- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you