“Young journalists should fight for their rights”

JK Bank

As long as sub-editors cum government servants continue to rule Kashmir journalism, we will continue to lose promising journalists to the government. This long era of government journalism in the Valley has to end, says NASEER A GANAI

Try to interact with journalists working with local newspapers in Srinagar, and you will come to know how harsh, conditions are in the newsrooms of Kashmir.

It is so bad that every young, capable and honest journalist wants to run away from these newsrooms. It is not that they don’t have any passion for journalism, or they don’t love the job, or that they don’t want to be journalists. They have passion for journalism. And over the years, by staying in the newsrooms of local newsrooms, they have proved that they can excel if provided better working atmosphere. Many of them who moved to national and international news agencies and newspapers, proved themselves.

Some frequently write in international publications which indicate that they can be better reporters and excellent writers. But then why is this urge to run away from newsrooms of local newspapers?

Recently State Information Department, University of Kashmir and the Central University came up with advertisements seeking applications for posts of Public Relation Officers.

Almost all journalists who were working with local media applied for these posts. And a number of them are expected to be selected. These people had worked with the local media for more than five years. Had they applied for accreditation, they would have easily got it.

Don’t accuse them of greed. After completing Masters in Journalism from University of Kashmir and other Universities, once these boys and girls join local newspapers, at first they are being paid nothing. They are recruited as interns, and during internship nothing is being paid. This bounded labour in the name of internship can last for a year or more. After a year newspaper owners feel that they should now post them as ‘staffers’. They employ them, but for a paltry sum of Rs 2000 to 3000. This ‘salary’, however, remains constant for years together.

It is increased to 8000 to 10,000 after many years and countless pleas. You have no health, medical insurances, no PF and no GP fund. Nothing. Anytime an editor, also the owner of the publication, can shoot you the termination letter. These days such orders are passed on by one email, saying you are no more a reporter. Thus having no proper recruitment and termination policy the newspapers in the Valley have rendered journalism a useless profession. They have rendered it so vulnerable that politics at times seems far decent profession.

In most of the newspapers it is the government employee, who work as sub-editor, has more say over decision making than the reporter who breaths journalism 24/7. government employee as journalists? You might be surprised at what I am saying. In Valley newspapers owners have employed government employees as sub-editors.

These government employees draw double salary and have secure jobs at both the places. They never use their bylines, and thus are free from any trouble and tension. This has caused a lot of tension among the regular reporters. And they see the government job, where a teacher or an information officer or clerk in bank draws
salary of over Rs 30,000 with all other benefits, as much more secure than working in a newsroom. So reporters here have got a notion that they could work as government servants and at the same time be sub-editors in newspapers. They think being an evening-journalist and a government employee by day increases your sphere of influence.

In all this what Kashmir is losing? It is losing a breed of honest and dedicated journalists, who think it is better to become a secure government employee and a journalist, rather than an insecure reporter who could be sacked anytime. For the past one year many good reporters left reporting and joined the government services in the Valley. Some are working in the banks. Ironically, after joining the government, they come back to newspapers, seeking job of ‘sub-editors’ in the evening.

This has marred journalism in Kashmir. As long as sub-editors cum government servants continue to rule Kashmir journalism, we will continue to lose promising journalists to the government. You have to end this long era of government journalism in the Valley. And as long as the newspaper owners in the Valley continue
to think that they have hired not reporters but bonded labour, journalism in local newspapers for graduates of mass communication department will continue to be a last option.

But what has to be done. Young journalists should fight for their rights. They should seek decent wages and raise the issues that confront them. Newsrooms of the Valley play havoc with health of reporters. I have not seen any journalist being given health insurance. If a journalist is not under any health insurance scheme, he is financially and psychologically vulnerable. If someone has to go through eye surgery due to working on computers for prolonged hours, he allows it to deteriorate rather than spending Rs 25000 to Rs 30,000 on surgery.

In the corporate sector here people are given health insurance for entire family and here they don’t give it to their employee. In case of accidents, bullet injuries or beating by police and security agencies, it is family of journalist who bears health expenses rather than organisation. At times an organisation simply disowns a reporter if due to a health related problem he has stay at home for a month or two.

At average journalist working local dailies earn nearly about Rs 4000 per month. One can understand what he or she can do in case of other exigencies. His dependants can never depend on him. If the collective salary of a government journalist (government employee and evening journalist) is nearly Rs 55000 per month, why
can’t newspapers owners pay regular reporters decent wages?

The regular reporters should take a call. And say no to this endless exploitation, which drains you physically and emotionally. In a conflict situation reporters have extra-tension and endless responsibilities without having any say in decision making. And if at the end of month, he is not getting decent salary, then what is all this tension and endless responsibility for? It is due to this reason that most of the reporters feel it is better to be an administrative services officer rather than a reporter. You have to work hard for three months for an administrative service job and then you have no worries once you get selected. Here you have to prove yourself
everyday! Here you have to come up with news stories every day and at the end of month you don’t even get a salary. Sometimes you get your salary after two months or three months.

Newspapers can get columnists from anywhere, who can write whatever they wish on opinion pages. Nobody is interested in that trash. But reporters do different job. They collect news, write features, look for investigative stories and break stories, take on government, talk about corruption, and at times bring down governments. It is reporters who run the paper. And it is reporters that Valley newsrooms are losing to the government. That should worry newspaper owners.

The newspaper owners should come up with job policy that could be lucrative for young reporters. They should bring professionalism in newspapers officers by denying employment to the government employees in the newspaper offices. There is no dearth of talent in the Valley. But you cannot harness the talent by endless exploitation. If a journalist applies for teaching job in University and gets it, he will realise what he has been doing as reporter in newsroom. As Assistant Professor he would draw a good salary. And we know what teachers do in the Universities. Except teaching and reading they do everything from backbiting to plagiarism.

In the journalism departments of University of Kashmir, Islamic University of Science and Technology, and the newly established Central University you will not find any teacher with a journalistic background. Except one teacher in the Mass Communication Department of Kashmir University no one has worked as reporter. They have been either bank clerks, or information officers. Unlike reporters who straightaway join a newsroom after doing Masters in Mass Communication and Journalism, the faculty in these three Universities had adopted a different course. After securing an MA in Mass Communication, they take the National Eligibility
Test and then joined a government service until the Universities advertise posts of Assistant Professors. Because only NET qualified persons can apply for job, they get it. And then they draw hefty salaries and pass judgment on copies of the reporters who despite meagre salaries and hard work come up with news stories every day. That is why all graduates of Mass Communication and Journalism Departments will tell you that they learn journalism in newsrooms rather than in Departments. There they teach you something which they themselves don’t know and understand.

There should be a change the way faculty is being recruited in Journalism Departments. Journalism Departments should have no regular faculty. Journalism cannot be taught by those who have never been in the newsroom. Instead Universities should hire senior journalists on contract basis for a year as faculty members. That would bring some journalism to journalism schools.

The present model is faulty and it will not produce any good result. It only discourages young reporters to remain in newsroom for long. They would prefer to be teacher in journalism schools rather than reporters. They would prefer to be Government employee and bank clerk rather than full time journalist.

They would prefer to be a PRO in a government department than full time journalists. That is why as long as fulltime journalists are not been given decent wages and preference over government employee-cum-journalists, journalism will not flourish in the Valley.

The time has come when newspapers owners should do some rethinking about the issue. And the time has come when full time reporters should bring this point forcefully and tell newspaper owners that those days of bonded labour have gone.

Naseer Ganai has worked for several years in both local and national media. He is a Srinagar-based journalist.

First published in The Hoot

Dear reader, we report people's voice...

Hence, we have not kept our content behind a paywall because we want their stories to reach everyone irrespective of reader's geographical location and economic status; but, you can help us remain independent by subscribing. The unbiased and free journalism needs resources and every contribution towards making mediascape a better place — however small or big — makes a difference. Subscribe today with as little as 39 rupees a month. Subscribe today »


  1. This is very true. I am not that Ishfaq who wrote against your take. I am the one who subscribes to your views and the one who would add a little to your opinion, which is based on facts at large. Here I go: I have studied journalism in mass communication department of kashmir university and I have not learned a single word from the faculty teaching there. Instead, what I learned was who is the enemy of who in the department and why is he or she the enemy of him or her or the other way round. One teacher who comes from a very wealthy family was against two teachers, one of them a backdoor entry, and the other one an arrogant so-called lecturer, who also writes op-eds for a newspaper, which has been a snake pit of exploitation and blackmailing. What trash that lecturer writes is like a piece of shit floating in the downtown drains, wherefrom a lot of students with mass communication degrees either became sub-inspectors in J&K police, or end up becoming bank clerks. Another thing i learned in the mass communication department was how to cheat. One lecturer has finished her PHD in TV. One day I stumbled upon her thesis and what she had written sent a feeling of disgust down my throat which made me vomit a very tasty mango shake which i had just had at university cafeteria. I started this sentence from cheating. Let me say what kind of cheating I learned. I learned how to copy-paste other people’s work and how to wash bottoms of your research guides, who come from outside of j&K, who dream to see beautiful kashmir in the company of tall and voluptuous Kashmiri women, also get picked up from the air-port, are treated kashmiri wazwan, and then taken for a shikara ride until he approves the thesis.

    Hey they don’t know what love means. Hatred runs deep in mass comm department. One day this rich lecturer whisked away a box of shirmal and the very same naseer ganai wrote a story about what we call the theft, and gave us a better picture of mass comm department (it was a good mock. i loved it! well done naseer ganai) such an embarassing situation it was, i can’t tell you. but i saw the rivals of that rich lecturer drawing pleasure from the news article. And naseer, who would be hated now, was praised as the phantom reporter of all jammu kashmir. In nut-shell what I mean is i mean that you should fire all the teachers of this defunct department and dissolve the department and change it into mass MBA department with expertise in banking and police services.

    Now i am coming to newspaper owners exploiting the reporters. i am among the founding persons of one of the best known newspapers of kashmir and unfortunately after i was fired by the owner, who happened to be my friend. Why was i fired…i was fired because i wouldnt let him dictate terms when it came to selecting news content for the next day’s edition. i also started to get invited in those poorly managed tea parties thrown by the grumpy politicians who expect a lot from kashmiri newspaper owners and in fact suck all the intellectual honesty out of them. By the time these owners become hollow, and thirsty for more invitations, the reporters and editors get the sense of how doomed their life can be, if they won’t apply for PRO posts, contractual teaching positions in unis like Islamic university, which is more blasphemous, less Islamic. Thanks to one of its great visionaries. So this is how it happens. And our naive sub-editors, who work like machines, also start looking into government job, as naseer puts it in a much better way. so let’s all stand up and raise our hands and say: “Zaalim sinde zulme nish bachaaw!”